Problem-Solving Strategies · Lesson 2 of 2
Reasoning and Checking
Test a conjecture with examples, but prove it with general reasoning when a universal claim is made. A single counterexample disproves a universal statement. Check solutions by substitution, units, estimates or a second method.
By the end, you can
- Identify patterns.
- Make and test conjectures.
- Justify mathematical statements.
- Check solutions using alternative methods where practical.
- Check signs and units.
- Avoid premature rounding.
- Distinguish exact values from approximations.
- Read diagrams and scales carefully.
- Verify that answers satisfy the original conditions.
Mathematical reasoning
Mathematical reasoning means justifying a conclusion rather than asserting it. In geometry that is naming the angle fact; in algebra it is showing the step; in statistics it is quoting the figure you are comparing.
A counterexample disproves a general claim with a single case: "every prime is odd" is disposed of by 2. But examples never show that a claim is always true — showing it works for three values is not enough, and a general argument needs a letter standing for any value.
To check an answer, substitute it back into the original problem: a solution to an equation should make both sides equal. Reverse the operation: if you divided, multiply back. Compare against an estimate. And ask whether the answer is sensible for what it describes.
Worth remembering
- Justify, do not assert. One counterexample disproves; examples never show a claim is always true.
- Check by substituting back, reversing the operation, or comparing with an estimate.
Common exam errors
A short list of errors accounts for a large share of lost marks, and knowing them is worth as much as more practice.
Not answering the question asked: finding x when the perimeter was wanted. Missing units, or using the wrong dimension. Rounding partway through instead of at the end. Losing a negative sign, particularly when expanding a bracket with a negative outside. Giving only one solution to a quadratic or to sin θ = k. Confusing area with perimeter, or circumference with area. Reading a graph scale wrongly. Forgetting to square or cube a scale factor for areas and volumes. Using the sloping side of a triangle instead of its perpendicular height.
In statistics: comparing only averages and not spread, or leaving the comparison as a statement about numbers rather than about the situation.
Most of these are caught by two habits — checking the answer is sensible, and re-reading the question after finishing to confirm it is what was asked.
Worth remembering
- Re-read the question after finishing: answer what was actually asked.
- Watch signs, units, rounding, and second solutions.
- Square or cube the scale factor for areas and volumes.
Worked example
Two odd numbers are 2m+1 and 2n+1; their sum 2(m+n+1) is even.
Practice
Warm-up · not marked
Check your understanding
Answer in your own words, then compare with the worked answer. Nothing here is saved or scored.
Worked answer
2 is prime and even, so it is a counterexample.
Check your method, units and explanation against it.
Marked practice
Set 1 of 6 · easiest first · Checked as you go, with the worked answer. Sign in or create a free account to save your progress.